Which occupations should we hold in higher prestige?
As I’ve been thinking about what job I might want to do next, I’ve been thinking about the different levels of prestige that society (1) gives to different occupations. What will my friends / enemies / society think of me if I take this job? Will I seem like I am achieving below my potential? Or will they think “wow he must be important if he has that job!”?
Maybe if we were ideal people we wouldn’t care about prestige. But as it is, prestige can be useful. It’s one of the ways that society conveys to us what societal roles are important. But sometimes a given role (public school teacher) doesn’t have the appropriate prestige given how important we think the role is in society (very).
This matters because jobs that have high prestige are more likely to attract more highly-motivated and highly-skilled people - all other things equal. Why do lots of people want to become professors at elite schools? It’s not the pay, or the work-life balance. Prestige plays a large part in it.
So as a society (2) we should constantly evaluate how much prestige we give to certain jobs. If we see that talented and hardworking people are going into jobs in numbers that are too high relative to how important that job is for society, that’s an indication that the job likely has too much prestige, and we should lower it (3).
So! Here are my off-the-cuff thoughts on which positions in society have too much, too little, or the right amount of prestige (4). Of course prestige is different among different groups of people, but I’m trying to generalize across “American society.” I’m shooting from the hip here, so if you think differently on any of these, let me know and I apologize for any stray bullets
Positions where the level of prestige should be lowered:
Consultants
Investment bankers
Lawyers (excluding public defenders)
Most jobs at most large NGOs
Working at a startup in Africa founded by ex-Consultants
Startup founder (in Silicon Valley)
Anyone who has any of the following words in their job title: “quantum”, “partner”
Positions where the level of prestige should be raised:
Public school teacher: Despite lots of people saying teachers should be valued more, most people don’t actually value them highly enough. Including the people who say they should be valued more. Probably including me
Startup founder (outside Silicon Valley)
Non-academic basic research position (e.g., at national labs)
Stay-at-home parents
Anyone who has any of the following words in their job title: “nuclear”, “social”, “child”
Positions with roughly the right amount of prestige
Medical professionals
University professors
PhD students in STEM
Parents (in general)
Engineers
Magicians of course. They live their act
—
Addendums from 9 August 2021: Based on input from others, I’ve added a clarifier to “lawyers”, added “inventors”, and removed “journalists” from “Positions where the level of prestige should be raised”. Thanks for everyone’s thoughtful input!
Journalism I think is an interesting one: While I do think it’s the case that better quality journalism would be valuable, raising the prestige of journalists is probably not the best way to do that. Too many people don’t think critically about the news they consume, so raising the prestige of journalists would likely lead people to out more blind faith in the news, which would be bad
—
1. “Society” being a word which here means “the people broadly in my circles or whom I want to impress, including but is not limited to my high school friends from Iowa, my college friends from MIT, that one Uber driver I had last year, my family, the professors I’ve had that I admire, the median person in Chicago, and that one guy who never seemed to like me so much.”
2. “Society” in this case being a word that means “the people broadly of the United States of America”
3. There are other factors here too of course, the biggest one being pay. But “society” (a word which here means See Footnote 2) doesn’t have as much say over pay - so let’s focus for now on what we can control
4. To be clear, I’m not saying that the jobs where prestige should be lowered are worthless (or that the jobs where prestige should be raised are the most important jobs). Just that society should hold these occupations in in lower (or higher) esteem than we currently do